The 2025 MLB All-Star Fan Vote is officially in—and the results have electrified the baseball world. Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani have not only emerged as the 2025 MLB All‑Star vote leaders but also set the tone for what’s shaping up to be one of the most thrilling Midsummer Classics in recent memory. With both superstars leading their respective leagues—Judge for the American League and Ohtani for the National League—this All-Star season is already packed with drama, fantasy baseball shakeups, and headline-worthy surprises.
“Judge & Ohtani clinch top votes—now let’s unpack what it all means for fans, fantasy players, and the All-Star legacy moving forward.”
🚨 2025 MLB All-Star Vote Leaders: Aaron Judge & Shohei Ohtani
In Phase 1 of the All-Star fan voting (June 4–26), Aaron Judge secured a league-best 4,012,983 votes, giving him the highest tally of any player and an automatic starting spot in the AL outfield (MLB.com). On the NL side, Shohei Ohtani grabbed 3,967,668 votes, locking in his position as the starting designated hitter, marking his fifth consecutive All-Star start (MLB.com).
The voting results underscore the continued dominance of these two superstars, with Ohtani’s two-way versatility and Judge’s raw power capturing the hearts—and ballots—of fans globally.
📊 Full Phase 1 Recap & Format Explained
The MLB All‑Star Fan Vote Recap begins with understanding the two-phase system:
- Phase 1 (June 4–26): Fans voted for the best players by position. The top vote-getter in each league earned an automatic starting spot.
- Phase 2 (June 30–July 2): The remaining top two finalists at each position (and top six outfielders) moved on to a runoff vote to determine the rest of the starters.
According to ESPN, the Phase 2 results were announced on July 3, with full All-Star Game starters confirmed for the game at Truist Park in Atlanta on July 15.
🌟 Starters Breakdown: Surprises, Legends & Snubs
Some big names made it, and some shocking snubs left fans scratching their heads. Here’s a breakdown:
🔥 Confirmed Starters
- Francisco Lindor, Cal Raleigh, Julio Rodríguez, Ronald Acuña Jr., Pete Crow-Armstrong, Kyle Tucker, and of course, Judge and Ohtani (CBS Sports).
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs. Paul Goldschmidt was a fan-fueled battle that defined Phase 2 in the AL at first base.
- Freddie Freeman, Will Smith, and Juan Soto (despite massive popularity) either barely made it or were stunningly left off final ballots.
💔 Notable Snubs
Despite excellent seasons, Juan Soto, James Wood, and Seiya Suzuki didn’t receive enough fan votes, stirring debates about the fairness and flaws of the current system (SBNation, Federal Baseball).
🐐 Legacy Picks
- Clayton Kershaw was named a Legend Pick, marking his 11th All-Star appearance (AP News).
- James Wood, at just 22, became the youngest All-Star, representing the Nationals’ future.
⚾ Fantasy Baseball Implications
This All-Star vote doesn’t just stir fan excitement—it has major implications for fantasy baseball managers.
📈 Judge & Ohtani Fantasy Impact
- Aaron Judge: With a .364/.453/.798 slash line in May, his selection reaffirms his fantasy elite status. Owners should anticipate a minor trade value boost as fan hype intensifies (Just Baseball).
- Shohei Ohtani: His fantasy value continues to skyrocket. His dual-role eligibility (hitter & pitcher) remains an asset, but fantasy owners should monitor his pitching volume post-All-Star due to potential innings limits.
📊 Position Battles That Could Shift Fantasy Stock
- Guerrero Jr. vs. Goldschmidt
- Jackson Holliday, José Ramírez, and Gleyber Torres: These Phase 2 contenders may see fantasy surges or dips based on their final selections (SI).
- NL Utility Options: Track players like Matt Muncy and Teoscar Hernández for late All-Star selection boosts.
📺 [Embed performance here]
🗓️ What’s Next: Timeline & Events
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| June 30–July 2 | Phase 2 voting window |
| July 3 | Starters announced |
| July 6 | Pitchers and reserves revealed |
| July 15 | 2025 MLB All‑Star Game at Truist Park, ATL |
Also watch out for the 2025 Home Run Derby lineup, which may feature returning legends and surprise entries, including rookie breakout names.
🧠 SEO Takeaways & Summary Keywords
All major search phrases used in this post:
- 2025 MLB All‑Star vote leaders
- Judge Ohtani All‑Star recap
- fantasy baseball All‑Star starters
- Aaron Judge 4,012,983 votes, Shohei Ohtani 3,967,668 votes
- MLB All‑Star Fan Vote Recap
- Phase 1 All‑Star voting June 4–26, Phase 2 All‑Star voting June 30–July 2
- Judge Ohtani fantasy implications
- All‑Star lineup surprises 2025, All‑Star snubs Juan Soto James Wood
- Cal Raleigh first Mariner starter, Clayton Kershaw Legend Pick
- two‑way player Ohtani fantasy impact
- Midsummer Classic Truist Park Atlanta July 15
🔗 External Sources Cited
- MLB.com – Judge All-Star vote leader
- MLB.com – Ohtani confirmed NL DH
- CBS Sports – Full list of 2025 starters
- ESPN – Vote explanation
- SBNation – Snubs & surprises
- AP News – Kershaw and Wood
- Federal Baseball – Wood snub analysis
- SI – Phase 2 battles
- Just Baseball – Fan voting deep dive
- MLB.com – Full roster release
🔗 Looking for More Amazing Recaps?
Check out more top trending content from the world of music and entertainment:
- BLACKPINK DEADLINE World Tour – JUMP 2025 Debut
- Keke Palmer’s Show-Stopping Macy’s Fireworks 2025 Performance
- Trisha Yearwood’s Classic Country Rendition at Macy’s 2025
- Eric Church Brings Fire to Macy’s Fireworks 2025
- Macy’s Fireworks 2025 Full Show Recap
- Sabrina Carpenter Live at BST Hyde Park 2025
- Ariana DeBose Shines in Broadway Tribute at Macy’s Fireworks
- Jonas Brothers Light Up Macy’s 2025 With Nostalgia
- Stormzy Dominates Roskilde Festival 2025
- AGT Star Andrea Wows with Hula Hoop World Record